Minimalenergy perturbations rapidly approaching the edge state in Couette flow
Type
Articles dans des revues avec comité de lectureDate
2015Journal
Journal of Fluid MechanicsAbstract
Transition to turbulence in shear flows is often subcritical, thus the dynamics of the flow strongly depends on the shape and amplitude of the perturbation of the laminar state. In the state space, initial perturbations which directly relaminarize are separated from those that go through a chaotic trajectory by a hypersurface having a very small number of unstable dimensions, known as the edge of chaos. Even for the simple case of plane Couette flow in a small domain, the edge of chaos is characterized by a fractal, folded structure. Thus, the problem of determining the threshold energy to trigger subcritical transition consists in finding the states on this complex hypersurface with minimal distance (in the energy norm) from the laminar state. In this work we have investigated the minimalenergy regions of the edge of chaos, by developing a minimization method looking for the minimalenergy perturbations capable of approaching the edge state (within a prescribed tolerance) in a finite target time T. For sufficiently small target times, the value of the minimal energy has been found to vary with T following a power law, whose best fit is given by E T1.75. For large values of T, the minimal energy achieves a constant value which corresponds to the energy of the minimal seed, namely the perturbation of minimal energy asymptotically approaching the edge state (Rabin etÂ al., J. Fluid Mech., vol. 738, 2012, R1). For T\geqslant 40, all of the symmetries of the edge state are broken and the minimal perturbation appears to be localized in space with a basic structure composed of scattered patches of streamwise velocity with inclined streamwise vortices on their flanks. Finally, we have found that minimal perturbations originate in a small lowenergy zone of the state space and follow very fast similar trajectories towards the edge state. Such trajectories are very different from those of linear optimal disturbances, which need much higher initial amplitudes to approach the edge state. The time evolution of these minimal perturbations represents the most efficient path to subcritical transition for Couette flow.
Files in this item
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.

CHERUBINI, Stefania; DE TULLIO, Marco; DE PALMA, Pietro; PASCAZIO, Giuseppe (American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME), 2013)This work provides a threedimensional energy optimization analysis, looking for perturbations inducing the largest energy growth at a finite time in a boundarylayer flow in the presence of roughness elements. The immersed ...

CHERUBINI, Stefania; DE TULLIO, Marco; DE PALMA, Pietro; PASCAZIO, Giuseppe (Cambridge University Press, 2013)This work provides a global optimization analysis, looking for perturbations inducing the largest energy growth at a finite time in a boundarylayer flow in the presence of smooth threedimensional roughness elements. ...

CHERUBINI, Stefania; DE PALMA, Pietro; ROBINET, JeanChristophe; BOTTARO, Alessandro (2011)This paper describes a scenario of transition from laminar to turbulent flow in a spatially developing boundary layer over a flat plate. The base flow is the Blasius nonparallel flow solution; it is perturbed by optimal ...

CHERUBINI, Stefania; ROBINET, JeanChristophe; DE PALMA, Pietro; ALIZARD, Frédéric (American Institute of Physics, 2010)The threedimensional stability dynamics of a separation bubble over a flat plate has been studied in both linear and nonlinear conditions. Using a global eigenvalue analysis, two centrifugal global modes are identified: ...

CHERUBINI, Stefania; DE PALMA, Pietro; ROBINET, JeanChristophe; BOTTARO, Alessandro (APS, 2010)Recent studies have suggested that in some cases transition can be triggered by some purely nonlinear mechanisms. Here we aim at verifying such an hypothesis, looking for a localized perturbation able to lead a boundarylayer ...