Comparison of Holmium:YAG and Thulium Fiber Lasers on the Risk of Laser Fiber Fracture
TypeArticles dans des revues avec comité de lecture
Objectives: To compare the risk of laser fiber fracture between Ho:YAG laser and Thulium Fiber Laser (TFL) with different laser fiber diameters, laser settings, and fiber bending radii. METHODS: Lengths of 200, 272, and 365 mu m single use fibers were used with a 30 W Ho:YAG laser and a 50 W Super Pulsed TFL. Laser fibers of 150 mu m length were also tested with the TFL only. Five different increasingly smaller bend radii were tested: 1, 0.9, 0.75, 0.6, and 0.45 cm. A total of 13 different laser settings were tested for the Ho:YAG laser: six fragmentation settings with a short pulse duration, and seven dusting settings with a long pulse duration. A total of 33 different laser settings were tested for the TFL. Three laser settings were common two both lasers: 0.5 J x 12 Hz, 0.8 J x 8 Hz, 2 J x 3 Hz. The laser was activated for 5 min or until fiber fracture. Each measurement was performed ten times. Results: While fiber failures occurred with all fiber diameters with Ho:YAG laser, none were reported with TFL. Identified risk factors of fiber fracture with the Ho:YAG laser were short pulse and high energy for the 365 mu m fibers (p = 0.041), but not for the 200 and 272 mu m fibers (p = 1 and p = 0.43, respectively). High frequency was not a risk factor of fiber fracture. Fiber diameter also seemed to be a risk factor of fracture. The 200 mu m fibers broke more frequently than the 272 and 365 mu m ones (p = 0.039). There was a trend for a higher number of fractures with the 365 mu m fibers compared to the 272 mu m ones, these occurring at a larger bend radius, but this difference was not significant. Conclusion: TFL appears to be a safer laser regarding the risk of fiber fracture than Ho:YAG when used with fibers in a deflected position.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Ho:YAG laser lithotripsy in non-contact mode: optimization of fiber to stone working distance to improve ablation efficiency DE CONINCK, Vincent; KELLER, Etienne Xavier; CHIRON, Paul; DRAGOS, Laurian B.; EMILIANI, Esteban; DOIZI, Steeve; BERTHE, Laurent; TRAXER, Olivier P. (Springer, 2019)Purpose: To evaluate how variable working distances between the laser fiber and the stone influence ablation volume. Methods: A laser fiber was fixed on a robotic arm perpendicular to an artificial stone. A single laser ...
How much energy do we need to ablate 1 mm3 of stone during Ho:YAG laser lithotripsy? An in vitro study PANTHIER, Frédéric; VENTIMIGLIA, Eugenio; BERTHE, Laurent; CHAUSSAIN, Catherine; DAUDON, Michel; DOIZI, Steeve; TRAXER, Olivier (Springer, 2020)Introduction: Holmium:yttrium–aluminium–garnet (Ho:YAG) is currently the gold standard for lithotripsy for the treatment of all known urinary stone types. Stone composition and volume are major determinants of the lithotripsy. ...
HADDAD, Mattieu; EMILIANI, Esteban; ROUCHAUSSE, Yann; COSTE, Frédéric; BERTHE, Laurent; DOIZI, Steeve; BUTTICÈ, Salvatore; SOMANI, Bhaskar Kumar; TRAXER, Olivier P. (Springer Verlag, 2017)Purpose: Holmium:YAG laser is the most used laser for urolithiasis. Generally, we use metallic scissors to cut the fiber tip to restore its effectiveness. Many cleaving methods have been described to avoid fiber damage and ...
PANTHIER, F.; LAPOUGE, Pierre; DOIZI, Steeve; DRAGOS, L.; BERTHE, Laurent; TRAXER, Olivier (Elsevier, 2020)L’étude in vitro de la lithotritie laser (LL) utilise des calculs humains (CH) ou synthétiques (CS). Devant l’augmentation de la pulvérisation laser (Dusting), peu d’échantillons humains sont disponibles. Les CS sont donc ...
Comparaison in vitro de l’efficacité statique ou dynamique des lasers Holmium :YAG et thulium fibré pour la lithotritie endocorporelle : impact de la vitesse de déplacement PANTHIER, F.; GERMAIN, T.; BERTHE, Laurent; DOIZI, Steeve; TRAXER, Olivier (Elsevier, 2020)La vitesse optimale de déplacement (VOD) de la fibre laser pour réaliser la pulvérisation lithiasique est une variable inconnue à ce jour, autant pour le laser thulium fibré (TFL) que pour le laser Holmium :YAG (Ho :YAG). ...