Linking objective and subjective modeling in engineering design through arc-elastic dominance
TypeArticles dans des revues avec comité de lecture
Engineering design in mechanics is a complex activity taking into account both objective modeling processes derived from physical analysis and designers’ subjective reasoning. This paper introduces arc-elastic dominance as a suitable concept for ranking design solutions according to a combination of objective and subjective models. Objective models lead to the aggregation of information derived from physics, economics or eco-environmental analysis into a performance indicator. Subjective models result in a confidence indicator for the solutions’ feasibility. Arc-elastic dominant design solutions achieve an optimal compromise between gain in performance and degradation in confidence. Due to the definition of arc-elasticity, this compromise value is expressive and easy for designers to interpret despite the difference in the nature of the objective and subjective models. From the investigation of arc-elasticity mathematical properties, a filtering algorithm of Pareto-efficient solutions is proposed and illustrated through a design knowledge modeling framework. This framework notably takes into account Harrington’s desirability functions and Derringer’s aggregation method. It is carried out through the re-design of a geothermal air conditioning system.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
COLLIGNAN, Arnaud; SEBASTIAN, Patrick; PAILHES, Jérôme; LEDOUX, Yann (2012)In most industrial design processes, the approaches used to obtain a design solution that best fits the specification requirements result in many iterations of the “trial-and-error” type, starting from an initial solution. ...
GIRARDEAU, Julian; PAILHES, Jérôme; SEBASTIAN, Patrick; PARDO, Frédéric; NADEAU, Jean-Pierre (ASME, 2013)Designing high performance cooling systems suitable for preserving the service lifetime of nozzle guide vanes of turboshaft engines leads to significant aerodynamic losses. These losses jeopardize the performance of the ...
Optimisation multicritère en conception de système photovoltaïque pour des maisons individuelles en contexte africain SEMASSOU, Guy-Clarence; NADEAU, Jean-Pierre; SEBASTIAN, Patrick; PAILHES, Jérôme; VIANOU, Antoine (Centre de développement des énergies renouvelables, 2013)The present proposed work treats the energy systems, of the autonomous photovoltaic type, coupled with batteries of storage, and intended for the cover of the needs of a rural home of Benin. These appropriate energy systems ...
SCARAVETTI, Dominique; NADEAU, Jean-Pierre; PAILHES, Jérôme; SEBASTIAN, Patrick (Inderscience, 2005)Early stages of the design process are often based on designers| experience; assumptions and irreversible decisions restricting the solution space are taken. It is difficult to take into account simultaneously every ...
Numerical modeling and experimental study of a box-section tube bundle thermal energy storage for free-cooling of buildings ROUAULT, Fabien; BRUNEAU, Denis; SEBASTIAN, Patrick; EKOMY ANGO, Serge; LOPEZ, Jérôme (Luisa F. Cabeza, 2012)A numerical model able to simulate the thermal behavior of an energy storage made of a bundle of rectangular tubes is presented. This model take into account the close-contact melting phenomenon due to the decreasign density ...