A new methodology to evaluate the performance of physics simulation engines in haptic virtual assembly
Article dans une revue avec comité de lecture
Purpose – In this study, a new methodology to evaluate the performance of physics simulation engines (PSEs) when used in haptic virtual assembly applications is proposed. This methodology can be used to assess the performance of any physics engine. To prove the feasibility of the proposed methodology, two-third party PSEs – Bullet and PhysXtm – were evaluated. The paper aims to discuss these issues. Design/methodology/approach – Eight assembly tests comprising variable geometric and dynamic complexity were conducted. The strengths and weaknesses of each simulation engine for haptic virtual assembly were identified by measuring different parameters such as task completion time, influence of weight perception and force feedback. Findings – The proposed tests have led to the development of a standard methodology by which physics engines can be compared and evaluated. The results have shown that when the assembly comprises complex shapes, Bullet has better performance than PhysX. It was also observed that the assembly time is directly affected by the weight of virtual objects. Research limitations/implications – A more comprehensive study must be carried out in order to evaluate and compare the performance of more PSEs. The influence of collision shape representation algorithms on the performance of haptic assembly must be considered in future analysis. Originality/value – The performance of PSEs in haptic-enabled VR applications had been remained as an unknown issue. The main parameters of physics engines that affect the haptic virtual assembly process have been identified. All the tests performed in this study were carried out with the haptic rendering loop active and the objects manipulated through the haptic device.
Cette publication figure dans le(s) laboratoire(s) suivant(s)
Visualiser des documents liés par titre, auteur, créateur et sujet.
Article dans une revue avec comité de lectureGONZALEZ-BADILLO, Germanico; MEDELLIN-CASTILLO, Hugo; LIM, Theodore; RITCHIE, James M.; GARBAYA, Samir (Emerald, 2014)Purpose – This paper aims to report the development and key features of a novel virtual reality system for assembly planning and evaluation called Haptic Assembly and Manufacturing System (HAMS). The system is intended to ...
Communication avec acteGONZALEZ-BADILLO, Germanico; MEDELLIN-CASTILLO, Hugo; LIM, Theodore; RICTCHIE, James; GARBAYA, Samir (Springer, 2012)Virtual assembly platforms (VAPs) provide a means to interrogate product form, fit and function thereby shortening the design cycle time and improving product manufacturability while reducing assembly cost. VAPs lend ...
Communication avec acteMEDELLIN-CASTILLO, Hugo; FLETCHER, C.; LIM, Theodore; RITCHIE, James M.; GARBAYA, Samir (Springer, 2012)Virtual Reality (VR) applications are employed in engineering situation to simulate real and artificial situations where the user can interact with 3D models in real time. Within these applications the virtual environment ...
Communication avec acteKOSMADOUDI, Zoe; LIM, Theodore; RITCHIE, James M.; LIU, Ying; SUNG, Raymond; BAALSRUD HAUGE, Jannicke; GARBAYA, Samir; WENDRICH, Robert; STANESCU, Ioana A. (Springer International Publishing, 2013)Computer-Aided Design (CAD) applications often promote memorable experiences for the wrong reasons. Coupled with complex functionality and poor user experience the learning curve is often steep and overwhelming. Invoking ...
Article dans une revue avec comité de lectureGARBAYA, Samir; MIRAOUI, Chekra; WENDRICH, Robert; LIM, Theodore; STANESCU, Ioana Andreea; HAUGE, Jannicke Baalsrud (2014)Virtual reality and virtualization are currently used to design complex systems and demonstrate that they represent the functionalities of real systems. However, the design refinement of the virtual environment (VE) and ...